Custom Cakes

Celebrate your special occasions — from birthdays to retirement parties — with fresh baked custom cakes from our in-store bakery in Sooke

We use the finest ingredients in all of our from-scratch-made custom cakes, fillings and buttercream, plus the freshest, ripest fruits from our produce department.

We offer a Standard style and all other custom cakes are Premium style with special toppings, custom drawing and/or whipped cream. On both styles, we customize the text for you.

Chocolate or Vanilla

Chocolate or white cake with your choice of fillings: Bavarian, lemon, chocolate fudge, cherry, raspberry or strawberry, finished with buttercream.

Black Forest

Chocolate cake with cherry filling and fresh whipped cream, finished with dark chocolate shavings and topped with fresh cherries.

Death by Chocolate

Chocolate cake filled with chocolate fudge, covered in chocolate buttercream and dark chocolate shavings with a dusting of cocoa powder.

Oreo Cookies & Cream

Chocolate cake with fudge and Bavarian buttercream, finished with Oreo cookie crumbs and vanilla buttercream, topped with Oreo cookies.
Also available in MINT Cookies & Cream


Layers of chocolate cake, fudge, white cake and strawberry filling, finished with chocolate and vanilla buttercream, white and dark chocolate shavings, and topped with chocolate-dipped strawberries.

Strawberry Shortcake

White cake with strawberry filling and finished with fresh strawberry whipped cream, white chocolate shavings, and — of course — fresh strawberries!

Lemon Coconut Cream

White cake filled with lemon, finished with lemon buttercream and toasted coconut.

Candy Blast

Choice of white or chocolate cake with Bavarian cream, covered in vanilla buttercream and a pile of gummy candies — a kids’ fave!

S’more Please

Chocolate cake with layers of fudge, marshmallows and crushed graham crackers, finished with chocolate buttercream, chocolate drip, and whole marshmallows and graham crackers with dark chocolate shavings.

Round7″ diameterServes 6-10$20$29
Square8″ x 8″Serves 10-15$25$38
1/4 Slab8″ x 12″Serves 15-20$30$42
1/2 Slab *12″ x 16″Serves 30-50$60$84
Full Slab *16″ x 24″Serves up to 100$120$169

* Half and full slab cakes must be paid for in advance.

Phone 250.642.2753 to Order

Our bakery is open for orders 7am to 7pm
24 hours minimum notice required

  • Please alert us when ordering if you have any allergy concerns.
  • We do not bake gluten or dairy free cakes, but we have options available in our Freezer Department (see our FAQ below).
  • If you wish to customize your cake, we’ll be happy accommodate you. Substitutions available at extra cost.
  • Cakes may not appear exactly as shown in these photos.
  • Prices are subject to change without notice.
  • 5% GST applicable.
  • Cakes are order by phone and pickup only. At this time, we do not offer online ordering or delivery.

“I would like to send a special thank you to Jesse for going above and beyond on the custom cake designs. She totally accommodated my request in such a creative and professional manner and her artistic cake decorating skills are amazing. She is such a treasure to have working at your store. Thank you so much.”

Alice Seba, Aug 2022


Do you offer gluten free or dairy free options?

At this time, we do not bake in-store gluten-free and dairy-free products. However, we do have some great options we bring in to meet this need, found in our Freezer Section:

  • Gluten-free: Wendell’s True Foods black forest cakes and pecan caramel Turtle cheesecakes
  • Gluten-free & Vegan (no dairy or eggs): Sweets From the Earth wild blueberry cheesecake, espresso cheesecake, and chocolate cake

How many letters/characters fit on top?

We can typically write 20-25 letters atop the 7″ round and 8″ square cakes (e.g. Happy Birthday plus a 10 letter name), 30 letters atop partial slab cakes and 40 letters atop full slab cakes.

What are your flavour options? Can I request a combination?

Our cake bases are chocolate or vanilla (white cake). Our fillings are Bavarian cream, lemon, chocolate fudge, cherry, raspberry or strawberry. And we have all the toppings mentioned above. Yes, any combination or substitution is available at extra cost. Please discuss details via phone.

Do you deliver?

Cakes are pickup in store only. At this time, we do not offer online ordering or delivery.

Phone 250.642.2753 to Order

Our bakery is open for orders 7am to 7pm
24 hours minimum notice required

Receive our specials in your inbox every Wednesday